Why Witnesses Matter Shedding Light on the Truth

Securing witnesses in the aftermath of a car accident is a fundamental and strategic step for the individuals involved. Witnesses offer advantages that can significantly impact the outcome of the subsequent legal proceedings. The significance of obtaining witnesses lies in their ability to serve as objective observers, impartial narrators, and critical contributors to the establishment of fault. Therefore, supporting the overall strength of the case.

Determining Fault

Witnesses can play a pivotal role in determining fault. Given the potential for conflicting accounts and subjective perceptions from the involved parties, witnesses provide an external and unbiased perspective. Their statements serve as a crucial source of independent evidence, offering clarity on the sequence of events leading up to, during, and after the accident. In legal context, where establishing liability is paramount, witness testimonies serve as essential building blocks. They contribute to a more comprehensive understanding of the circumstances surrounding the incident.

Creating an Unbiased Narrative

Witnesses contribute to the creation of a more reliable and unbiased narrative of the events. As neutral observers, their accounts carry inherent credibility. They offer an alternative viewpoint that can either corroborate or challenge the versions provided by the parties directly involved in the accident. This impartiality is especially valuable in situations where the emotional or personal investment of the individuals directly affected might color their recollection of events. The objectivity that witnesses bring to the table enhances the overall integrity and reliability of the information available for legal scrutiny.

Strengthening Your Case

Obtaining witness statements is not only about collecting perspectives on the accident. It is also about fostering a comprehensive and accurate representation of the incident. Witnesses can provide valuable details about environmental factors, traffic conditions, and any other relevant circumstances that may have contributed to the accident. This level of detail enriches the evidentiary pool, offering a more nuanced understanding of the events and providing a holistic backdrop against which fault can be assessed.

Gathering Evidence at the Scene

A seriously injured person should focus on what is necessary to obtain timely and appropriate medical attention. In less serious situations, any effort to document the scene will later assist the claim. Witness statements may sometimes vary due to differences in perception or recall. Physical evidence at the scene can corroborate specific details provided by witnesses. Such as skid marks, debris, or damage to vehicles.  With the advent of camera phones with video capabilities, it has never been easier to preserve evidence quickly and accurately. Skid marks may disappear in the first rain. If it is raining at the time of the collision, they may only be briefly visible on the pavement. Weather conditions can also impact the dynamics of an accident. Collecting evidence related to these factors can validate statements made by witnesses regarding the environmental conditions at the time of the incident.

Gathering evidence at the scene of a car accident serves as a critical foundation for assessing the accuracy and reliability of witness statements. It provides an objective and tangible record that can be referred to during insurance claims, negotiations, or legal proceedings.

Download our checklist of evidence needed to keep in your car.

Law Enforcement and Witnesses

Law enforcement officials, even when conducting a reasonable examination, clear the scene of hazardous debris upon documenting its location. While many law enforcement officials take photographs of the scene, this is not a given. The law official may take the photographs from limited understanding of the facts. Witness statements can help complement the physical evidence documented at the scene. The officer is also able to ask witnesses about specific details, such as the position of vehicles, the sequence of actions, and any contributing factors they observed.

Sometimes, one party is injured and unable to relate an accurate description of the events at the scene. The officer may report the collision solely from the perspective of the offending, arguably uninjured, motorist. Thereby forever slanting the investigation in favor of the offending party. If an officer can interview a witness, they can include these statements that may be in favor of the injured party in their accident reports. These reports become valuable sources of information for insurance claims and legal proceedings.

Investigating officers will only occasionally sweep the area for eyewitnesses. Motorists or pedestrians who stop to lend assistance are fruitful sources of information to assist in a claim. This is true even if a passing motorist saw nothing of the collision. His comments about the condition of the injured persons before medical attention arrives may be supporting evidence of a claim. Law enforcement’s immediate response to an accident can encourage witnesses to provide statements promptly.

How to Obtain the Right Witnesses

A list of witnesses with contact information may provide valuable information about disputed claims. People who saw the event, co-workers at scenes of industrial injuries, occupants of any involved vehicles are all invaluable. An injured person, especially if seriously injured, may be physically incapable of securing the information most needed. Moreover, if the claimant spent their first moments at the scene collecting evidence, it may be harder to prove the injuries were significant. While the lost information may make any case difficult to prove, securing the information may suggest little or no injury.

It is best to delegate someone else to secure the information at the scene. Perhaps a co-occupant of a vehicle, a friendly co-worker, a family member who can be called to the scene. The health and safety of the injured person is paramount, and nothing should be done to jeopardize the injury suffered. Often the police or investigating person talked only to the person causing the injury.  They never had the chance to speak with the injured party if they were taken to the hospital. If the person who just ran the red light is physically capable of giving an account that “I had the green light”, it may be very difficult to later prove the contrary.

It is essential to gather witness contact information at the scene of the accident. Try to get their names, phone numbers, and if possible, email addresses. Encourage witnesses to stay until police arrive, if applicable, and provide their statement to law enforcement. Having reliable witnesses can significantly impact the resolution of the accident, whether through insurance claims or legal actions.

A Car Accident Attorney Can Help

If securing such information at the time of the injury is impossible or impractical, early retention of an attorney can involve an advocate for your position. If attained early enough, your attorney may be able to preserve or reconstruct quickly vanishing information from the scene. Unfortunately, the trail can go cold very quickly. Time erodes memories. Weather changes the condition of the roadway. Physical evidence gets removed, cleared, or altered. Car accident attorneys can use all this information to build a strong case. An attorney can be an invaluable ally in a car accident case. They work to protect your rights, maximize your compensation, and guide you through the legal process. If you or someone you love suffers an injury in a car accident, contact our experienced car accident injury attorneys today.   We can help ensure you obtain the compensation you deserve.